快讯速递

Why NJ’s governor thinks Republicans are trapped in an X bubble

Why NJ’s governor thinks Republicans are…

Today I’m talking with Mikie Sherrill, who’s been New Jersey governor for just a little under a year, and you’ll hear her say her election was a preview of the …

A stylized illustration of NJ Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s formal headshot.

Today I’m talking with Mikie Sherrill, who’s been New Jersey governor for just a little under a year, and you’ll hear her say her election was a preview of the huge Democratic victories in these recent midterms because she ran on the dual themes of affordability and accountability.

So I wanted to ask the governor exactly how corruption became such an animating issue for voters, in an era of tech billionaires who own platforms like X and TikTok and who also now control huge swaths of local media and even national broadcast media like CBS News.

You’ll hear us get into the new era of influencer politics, which plays out as social video and takes its cues from rising stars like New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and how I think influence on platforms like Elon Musk’s X is starting to backfire in big ways for conservatives.

Verge subscribers, don’t forget you get exclusive access to ad-free Decoder wherever you get your podcasts. Head here. Not a subscriber? You can sign up here.

But the real story this election cycle might be the states. With President Donald Trump concentrating power in the executive branch, governors like Sherrill are starting to exercise their own power in ways that haven’t been tested in a long time.

This runs right into tech policy and anti-AI backlash, as states around the country try to address topics like child safety and Big Tech overreach in lieu of any form of meaningful federal regulation. That’s how politicians like Sherrill have found themselves at the forefront of the data center fight, online privacy, and age verification — all topics you’ll hear us dive into here.

We also dig into the Meta settlement, why Sherrill expects more Big Tech litigation, and what happens to privacy in the Flock and AI era. She had a lot of questions about the last one, and honestly, so do I. It’s a conversation I think we’re all going to be having for a while.

Before we get going, do me a favor and subscribe to Decoder on YouTube, where we put out new episodes every Monday and Thursday.

Okay: New Jersey governor Mikie Sherrill. Here we go.

This interview has been lightly edited for length and clarity.

Governor Mikie Sherrill, you’re the governor of New Jersey. Welcome to Decoder.

Well, thanks so much for having me. I really appreciate it.

I’m excited to talk to you. It’s after the midterms; there’s a huge blue wave, and you’re a Democrat.

I noticed.

Yeah. I noticed that you were saying, “New Jersey is like the bellwether,” and you “paved the way…” This is your big quote. Tell me about that, and tell me how you’re feeling about the midterms.

I’ll answer the easy question first. I feel great about the midterms. I feel absolutely fantastic about the midterms. And yeah, I was thinking about it because New Jersey has those off-year elections. So, there are very few statewide races — really only two in that cycle: New Jersey and Virginia. Right after Trump won, we started our campaign. And by right after, I mean, he won in November of 2024, and we started our campaign in November of 2024. What’s so interesting about New Jersey is that, even for a governor of this state, it’s still so retail. I don’t think a lot of other big states do as much retail, meaning I’m getting in front of thousands and thousands of people, sometimes per day, at small business stops, at diners, in their community… We have so many municipalities. I am able to go to gatherings of people up and down my state.

And that means that we always have a real pulse on what’s going on very quickly. After 2024, we had to get the vibe because it was different; people were furious. They wanted movement, they wanted change, and then suddenly you have Elon Musk with a chainsaw. People are scared, they don’t like what’s happening, and they want a leader who’s going to address it. And I think what we did in that time, because we heard from everyone, is really centered on what the race was about, and it was about affordability and accountability.

I know now that seems obvious… Yeah, it’s about affordability, and everyone knows that. I don’t think it was obvious in 2024 what it was all about. What was driving people? And in New Jersey, we were able to figure that out, and I think because the campaign was so incredibly successful, and we had such a huge win at the end of the day, that people then thought, oh yeah, that’s exactly the path. We’re all going to run on affordability and accountability, and that’s powerful in the Democratic Party. I think we’re at the center of our power when we’re fighting for working families, and that’s where we are right now, and I think it bodes really well for the future.

One of the really surprising aspects of this last election cycle was corruption leading the polls in several places. You don’t often see people on CNBC being like, “Our poll says corruption is the number one issue in America.” I think it was number two in The Guardian poll. I feel like I can connect corruption to all the tech CEOs being at the White House all the time, and to data centers. Is that a real connection, or is that just because I happen to live in the tech bubble?

So, as somebody who has worked with polling, good, bad, and everything in between, I would say, and not to sound like a broken record, we were talking about… And that corruption piece was part of the accountability, the affordability. And I was hearing about that anger at corruption on the trail, even from very small, modest businesses, tying it to Trump pocketing billions of dollars as their costs are going up. I think you’re exactly right. People are very upset at the tech billionaires, and when they’re hanging out at the White House, especially those flip-floppers. They’re all in on liberal values, and then they’re all in on Trump values. It’s just to make a buck. The reason corruption popped so much is people… It’s not just corruption; it’s the corruption that’s costing them money.

It’s Trump going into this Iranian war that he can’t explain and somehow making billions of dollars. It’s Trump trying to allow Russian diesel here, as everyone else is paying higher and higher gas prices, and everyone knows that Russia is funding Iran. And oh, by the way, the oligarchs are funding the wedding of Trump’s kid. Just so much corruption, and it’s tied, I think, specifically, to people’s ideas of their pocketbook and what’s making this go up. Everyone thinks it’s because Trump’s partly on the take here.

One of the things that I’ve been really thinking about is how people found out about the corruption, how they talked to each other about it, and why it became such an issue. And the reason I’m asking that way is, well, Elon Musk owns X, right? He bought a social media network. Larry Ellison and Oracle have some controlling stake in TikTok. Mark Zuckerberg owns Instagram. Skydance exists, and it owns CNN. The idea that the tech billionaires control the media, and have bought more and more of the media, was supposed to create even more of an epistemic bubble. We are going to tweet policy into reality is as much a part of Trump Two as anything, and people found out what they wanted to find out, and yet they had these conversations. I haven’t been able to figure out why; do you have a theory about that case?

There was a lot of corruption that we were trying to bring to the fore that was really hard to have people connect with. I think, for example, when we had Congress block some of the most high-end semiconductor chips so that we could win some of the technological battle against China, and Trump basically got paid off by the UAE, and then suddenly the floodgates were open. So, we had seen all of this cryptocurrency and stuff going into his pocketbooks. I suspect there’s a lot we don’t even know. But your point is really a good one because we were sort of saying he’s corrupt, and people sort of felt that he was corrupt, but the specifics of it were hard to bring out or get into the public consciousness. I tend to think that the interesting thing is… And look, I was very worried. I first ran in 2018, and I started to see the misinformation that people were getting online, and how people were getting algorithms driving them into more and more extreme places.

I was quite skeptical of some of this new media and what it might mean for people getting information. That is certainly one concern, but the flip side of that has become, as people have gotten used to some of that extremism and maybe started to filter it out a little bit, that there’s not much you can hide now, and I think that’s really good for democracy. So, for example, we had a problem here with our voter rolls. We discovered that the last administration had registered people who were not citizens, and they had not cleared them off the rolls. And so, we discovered this, and there were a lot of people saying, “Just put out a paragraph and just kind of duck and cover and hope it goes away. Sweep it under the rug a little bit.” And to me, that’s not accountability, that’s not what I ran on, and that’s not being a strong leader. Being a strong leader is saying, “Yeah, a problem happened, but I’ve got the solution to it, and I’m going to handle it.” And I think that breeds trust in government.

The reason that I maybe felt so strongly about this was that there’s no sweeping things under the rug in that way, and I think that’s really healthy. Meaning that if I had just put a little paragraph out, then the narrative would’ve gotten out anyway. I wouldn’t have been able to tell people exactly what happened, why it happened, and what we were doing about it; it would’ve been put out in whatever way somebody else wanted it out there. And so, I think what some people aren’t realizing is: you can’t hide much from the American people. The best thing you can do, and I think this is also my view of democracy and good government, is to be accountable to people. And to come forward strongly and say, this is what happened, this is why it happened, this is how I’m fixing it.

One of the things that I’m really curious about in that construction is how much of this cycle was dominated by politicians who had essentially learned the visual and social vernacular of influencers. And Zohran Mamdani here in New York City has obviously learned how to wield social media as well as any influencer. Abdul El-Sayed has learned that language. After the election, I think it was a House Oversight Committee that released what can only be described as an NBA hype reel with just the words “lawyer up” over and over again.

And there’s a part of me that’s like, this is incredibly effective. This is also a totally new brand of… Chuck Schumer should not do that. He doesn’t know how to do that. You need a new generation of politicians who speak this language, and sort of wield the algorithms against their owners in a very specific way. Do you think that’s permanent? Is that just a moment in time, or is influencer politics here to stay?

I think getting out on social media and being very present there feels very permanent to me. There certainly are people who do it incredibly well. But the interesting thing to me is that it’s not replicable because I think you have to be so authentic. And so, Zohran Mamdani is gifted; he’s like a social media prodigy. I think he does a great job. Don’t I wish, right? I think part of the reason I like what he does is that he comes across with a lot of humanity, a lot of empathy for people, reaching out to all different kinds of people, and it’s New York City, and it feels very authentic.

But I also like that empathy piece. I think some people take from the more bravado and maybe the Oversight Committee, this idea that social media has to be real… I mean, just that you have to be kind of an asshole, and you have to get out there, and that’s how you get attention, and you’re just… And I see some people trying to do that. Look, I was in the Navy, and sometimes I curse like a sailor. I do not like to do that online. Kids are online; I’m a mom too, and I’m the governor of the state of New Jersey, so I don’t have to be crass online. I have to have, I think, some respect for the office. And there are some people who I don’t think actually use salty language in back rooms, but somehow think that if they start dropping F-bombs online, they’re going to be seen as tough on stuff.

The performative nature for some people is, I think, what gets them in trouble, and I think if you are authentic… And look, I’m going to be frank here, and I’m sorry, I’m not going to have as many followers as Zohran Mamdani. I’m just not. He’s, like I said, a prodigy, or gifted. I’m going to get the information; I’m going to connect with people. There are times when things hit, because we do so much in New Jersey, and people love New Jersey, and so we have a lot of Jersey stuff we do, and people like it. Great. People here in New Jersey are addicted to the weather. Great. We sadly have a lot of weather events, so we’ll hype it up. But at the same time, I think it’s really important to connect in an authentic way. And I think sometimes what you’ve seen is people looking at influencers or others who are good, and I think during the Trump administration, there were a lot of, quite frankly, toxic male bros, and somehow they learned this lesson. And yet, as you look across the people that just won, like Talarico, Amy Acton, Rob Sand… They were great people. They were really great people.

And I think those are the things that, when they come across, can be so powerful. I tend to think some of those people aren’t going to have Mamdani’s following either, but you have to be making sure that you’re talking to your electorate, and you’re the person that they elected you to be. That might have been a little rambling, but I think a lot about how you connect with people in an authentic way.

I’m really curious about that connection between policy, results, and authenticity. I think with Mayor Mamdani, you can see that he’s always trying to connect the policy to the result, and he’s obviously, like you said, very gifted at it. I’ll also say, I think that Rob Sand victory video, where he recreated the Fleetwood Mac meme with the cranberry juice, is an all-time piece of political communication. I’m not sure what it communicated, other than it ruled, but there is-

Sometimes you just love it. What was the one from the Mississippi senator? “Pick another protein.” I thought that was so good.

Yeah, it was very good. But there’s a vernacular there, right? It’s a video vernacular. In the history of politics, like JFK is the television president, there’s a vernacular with social video that came out in this election. And I’m really glad you brought up the sort of toxic energy of the Trump bros, because they feel like an X… They’re Twitter people, and they do barbs on Twitter-

Interesting. And you’re feeling like the newer ones are on, what do you say, Instagram? Is that-

Yeah, they’re on Instagram; they’re video. They’re natively video in a very particular way.

Right. I mean, X just feels toxic.

There’s something there.

Especially once Elon took it over, right?

Actually, here’s my hottest take. I’m curious if you agree with this.

Okay, yeah, I want to hear it.

My hottest take is that this election proved that Elon’s purchase of Twitter was a failure across every dimension.

Anytime you’re saying something proved Elon Musk’s something something was a failure, I’m here for you. I’m here for your hot take.

Well, it’s smaller than it used to be; he’s lost users. He is not making more money than Twitter ever did. And by the way, I want to qualify this by saying criticism of Elon Musk’s Twitter is in no way praise of the previous Twitter ownership. This thing has always been a disaster. But it’s smaller than it used to be; it’s certainly not making more money, and it has lost its political influence. I don’t think Twitter or X drives the national political conversation the way it used to. And in fact, because it’s become a bubble, I think it has confused a bunch of Republican politicians. I think it has confused the tech industry.

I’m wondering if you see that, right? You’re talking about how we’re in bubbles, and there’s more fragmentation, that you have to be more transparent, but I’m wondering if you see the sort of collapse of X in terms of its political influence.

So, you know I’m biased, but I think this is just another reason New Jersey kind of gets it right, because there are so many people who are saying they were astroturfed. I had to learn a new term in my campaign: astroturf, meaning they thought it was grassroots, but it was really just kind of the turf. There’s this fake energy sometimes on social media that people think is where everyone is at, and you can sometimes, as a good candidate in a campaign, really create that sense that everybody agrees in some area, or build a group that is going to really push that online. And yet, if you are on the ground speaking to real people all the time, you can get a sense of whether or not social media is matching up with where people are actually at.

I think time and time again, there is a sense that what is going on, especially, I would say on X, can give you this false sense of a bubble, and a false sense of where people are at. And the interesting thing… I think moving away from X can maybe change a little bit of this. I do think a lot of reporters would… It’s just easy. It’s easy to go through X and get the little blah, blah, blah and say, “This is what’s happening.” And you can really miss a lot of what’s going on if that’s… So, yes, I think the bubble can really fool people.

What did you make of the JD Vance post on X distancing himself from Trump, blaming it all on the war, and then the Hegseth video where he said, “Go ahead and try to impeach me.” Because those feel like pure X, like they’re talking to one audience in a small place. What’d you make of them?

If he wants to be impeached, I’m sure he can find somebody to do it. Yeah, let’s do it, let’s go. I think that bravado feels so 2024, and when you see the young men, especially, who I think were captured in… People felt like they were really in the movement, in the MAGA movement in 2024. As they are graduating, as they aren’t seeing any jobs, as they’re realizing they’re not going to be able to afford a house for many, many years, or even to be able to move out of their parents’ house, I think you are seeing a real swing away. Like it’s all fun and good if you’re at some loud rally where there’s a lot of music playing and you can be a tough guy, and you feel like that’s your team, like a sports event, but it’s not so fun and funny when you can’t get a job.

And so, that feels almost very 2024 to me and kind of missing the moment. That’s what’s so interesting about social media too. I think it moves very quickly. So, you might be the darling of whatever movement you’re in, and a couple years later you sound very tone-deaf.

I have one more question about the election and what it means. And I want to talk about New Jersey more specifically.

Trump Two has really been dominated by an almost anti-federalism. He tried to centralize a lot of power in the federal government, and the first AI bill the House passed was a 10-year moratorium on any state-level AI policy. There was a lot of, “We’re going to take power at the federal level. We’re going to bribe the states in various ways or punish the states if they don’t do what we say.” Now you’ve got a lot of democratic power across the whole government, in a bunch of state houses, in the federal government.

Do you think that’s going to swing back? Do you think we’re going to see more state-level policy? Do you think we’ll see more unification between what’s happening in all the democratic states and in Congress, or do you think we’ll see more experimentation?

I was listening to a political science person suggest that because of the way the US government is set up, there’s always going to be power that moves into a vacuum. And so, you saw the president taking all this power at the federal level; Congress was totally co-opted, and he had the presidency, the cabinet, and then he had the courts. So, you really did see the power moving to the people, and you started to see the people really engage more, as led by the states. In some of the governors’ offices and the state legislatures, that’s where power started to move to stand against what Trump was doing.

So I was so excited about Gina Hinojosa down in Texas. The biggest swing in my race was the Latino vote. I mean, we’re talking 18/22 points, which was a real precursor to some of that swing with the Latino vote in the other states in 2024. I just started looking around. Look, everybody’s talking about Talarico, so he’s bringing tons of people to the polls, and you have Bobby Polito, Johnny Garcia. I mean, you were seeing huge movements in their districts. Then Gina was saying, “Look, we have fielded congressional candidates in every race across the state, and so that’s going to bring people out.” I was just like, I think Gina’s got a great shot here. So, we did this big event for her three weeks before the race. Just thinking, we’ve got to get her some support here because I think she can do it.

And the reason I was so excited is, if you think about it, if we have California and the California governor, the Texas governor, and we have the New York governor… Man, we have a lot of the economy of the United States of America, and we can do a lot. We are moving into the state power.

So, for example, Trump said he was going to purchase Russian diesel. He has Russian diesel coming here. Now, I can’t tell you how opposed I am to that.

Right, you wanted to block it at the Port Authority [of New York and New Jersey], right?

Right, because they said they were coming to New Jersey. So, Russia is against Ukraine. I’m very opposed to their war against Ukraine. They are also supporting Iran, which we are currently at war with. I’m very opposed to the Iranian war, but they are killing Americans because we’re at war with them, and Russia is funding them. I mean, how can you, as the President of the United States of America, be putting money into the coffers of Russia? It is not acceptable on every single level, and it, oh, by the way, is illegal, because of laws that Congress has passed. I said, “It’s not coming into New Jersey.” But the states don’t traditionally have a lot of power here.

What we did was put every port and every business on notice in New Jersey that it was illegal. We charted out why it was illegal, and what laws Congress had passed, why what Trump and Bessent said was wrong — they were wrong on the law — and then we reminded everyone that the statute of limitations runs for five years, so don’t count on not getting caught on this one. And so far, we’ve seen a couple of ships turn away; I think we’re hearing that people are becoming very concerned about this, and not interested in it.

If somebody had told you that the state of New Jersey could turn back the president from importing oil into this country, you would’ve been skeptical, but that’s the kind of power states are moving into at the moment and using every tool we have. It’s not that we don’t have tools; it’s just that it’s a muscle that hasn’t been exercised in this way in a long time.

So, if we look to Texas, California, New York, along with New Jersey and other states, and there’s a bunch of Democratic ones now, if we want to — and we do — protect people from the downside risks of AI, we don’t need the federal government to do that. We can act as states. We can move in these ways that I think are very powerful, and have just become, after Tuesday, a lot more powerful.

Yeah, I’m fascinated by this dynamic.

Me too.

Especially with a heavily Democratic Congress, but then President Trump, who is threatening to veto everything. Some balance of power will shift to the states in some meaningful, potentially long-lasting way. It’s unclear exactly how that will work, but I think it will probably be the long-lasting story of this cycle.

I want to ask about New Jersey then, in that context. A year, not even a year into your first

原文出处:The Verge (本文由聚合程序自动采集,版权归原作者所有)